A new ship under fire
Prince of Wales entered the action with a crew still gaining experience of its new ship. Tovey’s despatch records Leach’s assessment that she had only recently become reasonably ready for her first operation. When Hood was destroyed, the surviving battleship had to continue fighting while taking hits herself. B11
The gunnery report describes faults that had persisted through training. Civilian specialists from the builders were still aboard, assisting the turret crews. The installed armament was therefore a poor guide to how many guns could keep firing throughout the action. B29
Inside the gun mountings
The 14-inch main battery and 5.25-inch secondary guns had separate duties. Within the main battery, the report distinguishes failures in particular guns and loading mechanisms. A displaced shell jammed Y turret’s shell ring during the turn away; the turret could not immediately resume fire. B turret, by contrast, reported no mechanical defect during the first action. B29
Those details matter because “the guns failed” is too broad. The ship’s firepower changed during the engagement, and surviving equipment still required trained people, ammunition supply and a usable firing bearing.
Why Leach withdrew
Damage to the bridge and directors, the loss of Hood and the state of the main armament shaped Leach’s decision to break off under smoke. Tovey reproduces his expectation that stronger British forces could concentrate later. Wake-Walker judged Prince of Wales in her condition at that moment unable to match Bismarck alone, and continued shadowing. That judgement was about an actual damaged ship, rather than a permanent ranking of battleship designs. B11
Read The loss of Hood and The Pursuit together: the withdrawal preserved a ship, but it also left the British dependent on maintaining contact until help arrived.
The detailed gun failures are currently checked through a modern transcription. The original gunnery enclosure still needs page-by-page comparison.
